Rating the Alpha Flight Characters

[syvalois]

In the most important character, you forgot Heather. And I guess you have a soft spot for underdogs, because your choice of favorite is really strange or shall we say "unusual". I don't even remember who is Feedback. As Puck you mean Zuzha? them you forgot Judd also.

[mos_def]

Im kind of late on this but better late then never, eh. Ill rate them from A-F

Alpha Flight:
B- Aurora (Beaubier, Jeanne-Marie)
good to have but not a must IMO
D- Box III (Walter Langkowski)
didnt care much for him in Box
A- Guardian I (Hudson, James MacDonald)
he started the whole thing
A- Guardian II (Hudson, Heather MacNeil)
she carried the whole thing when Mac was gone
B- Langkowski, Wanda
I actually like her arc
B- Northstar (Baubier, Jean-Paul)
see Aurora
A- Puck I (Judd, Eugene Milton)
heart and soul of team
A- Sasquatch I (Langkowski, Walter)
same as Puck
B- Snowbird (Thompson, Ann)
she gets credit cuz she was an original but what useful thing has she done except kill our loved Sassy and marry Yukon Jack
B- Talisman II (Twoyoungmen, Michael) [AKA. Shaman]
he makes my top 5

Beta Flight:
B- Box IV (Jeffries, Madison)
love the guy in Box armor or not
C- Marrina (Smallwood, Marrina)
I didnt care for her in Alpha, hated her in Avengers
B- Talisman I (Twoyoungmen, Elizabeth)
she uber powerful

Gamma Flight:
C- Box I (Bochs, Roger)
poor Roger but died trying to save Alpha from Scramble
D- Gemini
who?

Omega Flight:
C- Box II (Jerome Jaxon)
he killed Mac, hate him
C- Courtney, Delphine
ditto
B- Crawley, Lillian Diamond Lil
she has become a good Alphan
B- Flashback
for some reason I like the guy
C- Whild Child
Xmen get Logan we get stuck with Kyle
C- Smart Alec (Thorne, Alec)
First Flight flunkie, but he did bring back Walt from Limbo

New Alpha Flight Team:
D- Centennial (Princeton, Rutherford)
boring
C- Major Mapleleaf II (Saddler, Louis Jr.)
if his horse didnt give him his powers then he would get higher grade
B- Nemesis
the sword is awesome
B- Yu, Zuzha (Puck 2)
Pucks daughter gets credit for that
B- Yukon Jack (Yukotujakzurjimozoata)
I like his full name and the way he talks

OTHERS:
C- JADE DRAGON
the look was cool, poor HoM casuality
C- WINDSHEAR
I didnt care for him
B- PERSUASSION
I think they used her pretty well
D- PATHWAY
didnt care for her
D- GOBLYN
I rather have Wildchild
C- MANIKIN
to me he was useful, especially Apeman, Proto and Highbrow
C- FEEDBACK
came in when vol 1 was dying down in intrest for me
F- WYRE
I hate this guy as much as....
EXPELLED-EARTHMOVER
hate the look
C- WITCHFIRE
daughter of Belasco could bring good future stories
D- SILVER
deceased
D- AURIC
deceased
C- MANBOT
I liked the automotive arsenal on legs
B- RADIUS
brash and decent
C- FLEX
a bigtime wuss
C- GHOSTGIRL
decent character
A- GENTRY
he gets an A (I wonder why, maybe Mac Hudson can speak for him.)
C- GARY CODY
traitor

[suzene]

The Byrne-era headliners, just for fun...

Aurora (Beaubier, Jeanne-Marie) - 9
I love this girl, really. Even if Alpha Flight had never had to attack/fend off attack from a single super-villian, Jeanne-Marie's antics would have caused enough internal conflict to keep the book going for a year.

Guardian I (Hudson, James MacDonald) - 8
Poor Mac. He tried so hard, really. Let this be a lesson people...never stand too close to the boyscouts. They always wind up getting blowed up real good.

Guardian II (Hudson, Heather MacNeil) - 5
OK, I need to make a distinction here. I like Heather. I disliked Heather getting in the suit. I think the untrained civilian widow inheriting leadership of a bunch of mentally unstable supers was a bad, bad, bad, bad idea. I dunno, I'd have much rather have seen her in capacity more like Oracle's in 'Birds of Prey' rather than trying to fill Mac's shoes.

Northstar (Baubier, Jean-Paul) - 11
Abrasive, aloof, secretive, egotistical pill...and also strongly principled, unfailingly loyal to his sister, and generally in need of a hug. I cannot help but love this guy, even as I suppress the urge to smack him across the back of the head.

Puck I (Judd, Eugene Milton) - 6
Kind of cool, talked big, and gets one hell of a spike on the 'man, your life sucks' o-meter, but never really did all that much.

Marrina - 7
OK, the Plodex storylines were just damned silly, but you've got to admire someone with enough joy in them to make Namor smile and enough good sense to hang on to him.

Sasquatch I (Langkowski, Walter) - 6
Langkowski gets bonus points just for giving the twins something pretty to fight over. Not so thrilled by the whole experimenting on his mentally unstable girlfriend episode, though.

Snowbird (Thompson, Ann) - 9
Beautiful, primal, aloof and ten times the goddess Storm is, with with bloodline to back it up.

Talisman II (Twoyoungmen, Michael) [AKA. Shaman] - 6
Good concept, interesting execution, docked points for being a deadbeat dad.

Suzene

[cmdrkoenig67]

My list...

Dana

Alpha Flight:

Aurora (Beaubier, Jeanne-Marie) 10
Box III (Walter Langkowski) 4
Guardian I (Hudson, James MacDonald) 7
Guardian II (Hudson, Heather MacNeil) 10
Langkowski, Wanda 0
Northstar (Baubier, Jean-Paul) 10
Puck I (Judd, Eugene Milton) 10
Sasquatch I (Langkowski, Walter) 10
Sasquatch II 3
Snowbird (Narya) 10
Talisman II (Twoyoungmen, Michael) [AKA. Shaman] 6
Diamond Lil (Crawley, Lillian)8
Box IV (Jeffries, Madison) 7
Marrina (Smallwood, Marrina) 7
Talisman I (Twoyoungmen, Elizabeth) 10
Box I (Bochs, Roger) 7
Centennial (Princeton, Rutherford) 7
Major Mapleleaf II (Saddler, Louis Jr.) 6
Nemesis 8
Yu, Zuzha (Puck 2) 6
Yukon Jack (Yukotujakzurjimozoata) 6
Windshear (Colin Ashworth Hume) 8

Others:

Persuasion(Kara Killgrave) 8
Pathway 7 Hate the codename
Goblyn 7
Manikin 5
Feedback 6
Wyre 7
Earthmover (Chuck Moss) 5
Witchfire 7
Silver 5
Auric 5
Manbot (Berney Lachenay) 4
Radius (Jared Corbo) 6
Flex (Adrian Corbo) 6
Ghost Girl (Lilli) 5



Villains:

The Master(Eshu) 10
Caliber 8
Deadly Ernest (Ernest St Ives) 9
Gilded Lily (Lillian Von Loont) 10
The Wendigo 10
Dreamqueen 10
Pestilence 8
Pink Pearl (Pearl Gross) 6
The Plodex 9

The Great Beasts 10 I don't want to rate them seperately because I think they're all cool.


Omega Flight:

Box II (Jerome Jaxon) 10
Courtney, Delphine 10
Crawley, Lillian Diamond Lil 8
The Master/Eshu (Former Leader) 8
Flashback 9
Whild Child 9
Smart Alec (Thorne, Alec) 5
Miss Mass 6
Tech-Noir 7
Strongarm 6
Sinew 6
Brain-Drain 7

[darc_light]

Wildchild-10
Wyre-9 (Not on the list, but a cool guy nontheless)
Nemesis-9
Flex-7
Marrina-7
Manniken-5
Aurora-0
Eshu-0


I can't think right now

[kozzi24]

Alpha Flight:
9- Aurora (Beaubier, Jeanne-Marie)
0- Box III (Walter Langkowski)
2- Guardian I (Hudson, James MacDonald)
10- Guardian II (Hudson, Heather MacNeil)
0- Langkowski, Wanda
10- Northstar (Baubier, Jean-Paul)
10- Puck I (Judd, Eugene Milton)
10- Sasquatch I (Langkowski, Walter)
0- Sasquatch II
2- Snowbird (Thompson, Ann)
9 - Shaman (Twoyoungmen, Michael)

Beta Flight:
7 - Box IV (Jeffries, Madison)
7 - Marrina (Smallwood, Marrina)
5 - Talisman I (Twoyoungmen, Elizabeth)

Gamma Flight:
dead -Box I (Bochs, Roger)
2- Gemini

Omega Flight:
7- Box II (Jerome Jaxon)
5- Courtney, Delphine
5- Crawley, Lillian Diamond Lil
0- Eshu (Former Leader)
2- Flashback
6- Wild Child
4- rt Alec (Thorne, Alec)

New Alpha Flight Team:
3- Centennial (Princeton, Rutherford)
5- Major Mapleleaf II (Saddler, Louis Jr.)
6- Nemesis
0 -Yu, Zuzha (Puck 2)
0 -Yukon Jack (Yukotujakzurjimozoata)