Rating the Alpha Flight Characters

[-K-M-]

Hey just want to gauge on which is your favorite Alpha Flight characters are. This is just for my own personal use, just to see who likes whom, because I was surprised to read in one thread that so many people liked Marrina.

Below is a list and if you want you can write pros and cons and an explanation why you give them a rating out of 10……10 being your favorite, 5 their average, 0 being you want them dead.

Sorry wasn’t sure how to organize some, because some have been in all the factions.

Alpha Flight:
Aurora (Beaubier, Jeanne-Marie)
Box III (Walter Langkowski)
Guardian I (Hudson, James MacDonald)
Guardian II (Hudson, Heather MacNeil)
Langkowski, Wanda
Northstar (Baubier, Jean-Paul)
Puck I (Judd, Eugene Milton)
Sasquatch I (Langkowski, Walter)
Sasquatch II
Snowbird (Thompson, Ann)
Talisman II (Twoyoungmen, Michael) [AKA. Shaman]

Beta Flight:
Box IV (Jeffries, Madison)
Marrina (Smallwood, Marrina)
Talisman I (Twoyoungmen, Elizabeth)

Gamma Flight:
Box I (Bochs, Roger)
Gemini

Omega Flight:
Box II (Jerome Jaxon)
Courtney, Delphine
Crawley, Lillian Diamond Lil
Eshu (Former Leader)
Flashback
Whild Child
Smart Alec (Thorne, Alec)

New Alpha Flight Team:
Centennial (Princeton, Rutherford)
Major Mapleleaf II (Saddler, Louis Jr.)
Nemesis
Yu, Zuzha (Puck 2)
Yukon Jack (Yukotujakzurjimozoata)

[Mokole]

Madison Jeffries (Box) is my favorite, so I'd give him a 9. If he was written with a stronger personality, he'd get a 10.

I like characters with cool powers that really can't work, like flight and such. Phasing into metal, make metal alive, that's nonsense, no wonder I like it. Same with Feedback and Windshear, just nutso but cool powers.

Nemesis, Witchfire, Ghost Girl, Puck, Zuzha, Major Maple Leaf get over 5, too. Maybe more, but I'm tired.

[-K-M-]

Well that's a start, thanks.

Anymore comments?

[JohnnyCanuck]

Alpha Flight:
Aurora (Beaubier, Jeanne-Marie) *8*
Box III (Walter Langkowski) *9*
Guardian I (Hudson, James MacDonald) *9*
Guardian II (Hudson, Heather MacNeil) *9*
Langkowski, Wanda *3*
Northstar (Baubier, Jean-Paul) *9*
Puck I (Judd, Eugene Milton) *9*
Sasquatch I (Langkowski, Walter) *9*
Sasquatch II
Snowbird (Thompson, Ann) *8*
Talisman II (Twoyoungmen, Michael) [AKA. Shaman] *7*

Beta Flight:
Box IV (Jeffries, Madison) *7*
Marrina (Smallwood, Marrina) *9*
Talisman I (Twoyoungmen, Elizabeth) *9*

Gamma Flight:
Box I (Bochs, Roger) *7*
Gemini *3*

Omega Flight:
Box II (Jerome Jaxon) *8* Killed off to fast
Courtney, Delphine as hot chick *7* as robo chick *4* as Mac *5*
Crawley, Lillian Diamond Lil *5*
Eshu (Former Leader) *3*
Flashback *4*
Wild Child *5*
Smart Alec (Thorne, Alec) *5*
A lot of these guys stuck a bit like red shirt ensign guys on star trek . Expendable story filler not to be taken seriously for any long term.
New Alpha Flight Team:
Centennial (Princeton, Rutherford) *7*
Major Mapleleaf II (Saddler, Louis Jr.) *8*
Nemesis *6* The revealing of her face lessened the character for me she was supposed to be so scary and she's just a regular girl
Yu, Zuzha (Puck 2) *7* had some potential with a writer who knew how to use the word "eh?"
Yukon Jack (Yukotujakzurjimozoata) *6* lots of unexplored potential.

Villians
Tech Noir *8*
The rest of the new Omegas *3*
'cept for the cat guy who's name escapes me *5*
Master of the World *7* Got a bit of potential I think.
Gilded Lily *7*
Diablo *5*
Pink Pearl *8*
her gang *6*
Super Skrull *6*
Pestilence (sp) *8*
Dream Queen *9*
Nightmare *5*
Marrina Plodex ***** *9*
Great Beasts *8*
Deadly Earnest *8*


My opinion anyway.

[JohnnyCanuck]

oh yeah forgot

Purple Girl *9*
Witchfire *8*
Talisman II (Michael Twoyoungmen) *7*
Manikin *7*
Ghost Girl *7*
Murmur *7* ok ok she's just purple girl and Aurora mixed in one but a bit of writing and direction she'd be ok. and who doesn't like a french pastry. Put your hand down HappyCanuck.
Scramble *2*

If I think of more I'll add 'em. Some I didn't add because I don't care enough to rate the.

Johnny Canuck

[syvalois]

oh yeah forgot

Murmur *7* ok ok she's just purple girl and Aurora mixed in one but a bit of writing and direction she'd be ok. and who doesn't like a french pastry. Put your hand down HappyCanuck.

Don't comment, don't comment ,everyone know how you think of Murmur and her ?%$&?@&$?%#! fake %?%&#&#\&_)(*&?% accent and her 2#$#\#$%?&*_)(*& stereotype $?*&@?%!$#&?%*%$%$ which again can't make a difference between a @!$(*&?%$#$%?&**&$ french wowen and a #&?(**&&?%#%?&* Québécoise and more so a @#$?%&%# french canadian.

[JohnnyCanuck]

oh yeah forgot

Murmur *7* ok ok she's just purple girl and Aurora mixed in one but a bit of writing and direction she'd be ok. and who doesn't like a french pastry. Put your hand down HappyCanuck.

Don't comment, don't comment ,everyone know how you think of Murmur and her ?%$&?@&$?%#! fake %?%&#&#\&_)(*&?% accent and her 2#$#\#$%?&*_)(*& stereotype $?*&@?%!$#&?%*%$%$ which again can't make a difference between a @!$(*&?%$#$%?&**&$ french wowen and a #&?(**&&?%#%?&* Québécoise and more so a @#$?%&%# french canadian.

LOL , I knew I'd get a rise out of you . No stereotypes are intended on my part. If she was mexican we'd still like her if she's drawn pretty. So long as she's not saying" Si " " eet's bueno" etc. I also disapproved of Murmur's "Accent"

End the bad stereotypes in comics speech. I agree. Now let's rate the alphans, People

[HappyCanuck]

oh yeah forgot

Murmur *7* ok ok she's just purple girl and Aurora mixed in one but a bit of writing and direction she'd be ok. and who doesn't like a french pastry. Put your hand down HappyCanuck.

Hey now, leave me out of this! I have great respects for ALL pastry. Pastry is good. It's those French Pasties that leave a lot to be desired.

Don't comment, don't comment ,everyone know how you think of Murmur and her ?%$&?@&$?%#! fake %?%&#&#\&_)(*&?% accent and her 2#$#\#$%?&*_)(*& stereotype $?*&@?%!$#&?%*%$%$ which again can't make a difference between a @!$(*&?%$#$%?&**&$ french wowen and a #&?(**&&?%#%?&* Québécoise and more so a @#$?%&%# french canadian.

LOL, quite the mouth you have, Mme. Valois. I didn't know you could PUT @!$(*&?%$# and %#%?&* in the same sentence. Isn't that a bit contradictory?

[ladymako71]

oh yeah forgot

Murmur *7* ok ok she's just purple girl and Aurora mixed in one but a bit of writing and direction she'd be ok. and who doesn't like a french pastry. Put your hand down HappyCanuck.

Don't comment, don't comment ,everyone know how you think of Murmur and her ?%$&?@&$?%#! fake %?%&#&#\&_)(*&?% accent and her 2#$#\#$%?&*_)(*& stereotype $?*&@?%!$#&?%*%$%$ which again can't make a difference between a @!$(*&?%$#$%?&**&$ french wowen and a #&?(**&&?%#%?&* Québécoise and more so a @#$?%&%# french canadian.

Oh yeah that got her going! lol

I am personally a Northstar fanatic...those who know me well, know why.


now...as I have seen so far from my catching up:

Alpha Flight:
Aurora (Beaubier, Jeanne-Marie) *7*
Guardian I (Hudson, James MacDonald) *9*
Guardian II (Hudson, Heather MacNeil) *9*
Langkowski, Wanda *4*
Northstar (Baubier, Jean-Paul) *10*
Puck I (Judd, Eugene Milton) *9*
Sasquatch I (Langkowski, Walter) *10*
Snowbird (Thompson, Ann) *6*
Talisman II (Twoyoungmen, Michael) [AKA. Shaman] *8*

Beta Flight:
Box IV (Jeffries, Madison) *6*
Talisman I (Twoyoungmen, Elizabeth) *10*

New Alpha Flight Team:
Centennial (Princeton, Rutherford) *9*
Major Mapleleaf II (Saddler, Louis Jr.) *6*
Nemesis *7*
Yu, Zuzha (Puck 2) *8*
Yukon Jack (Yukotujakzurjimozoata) *6* I agree with JC on this one about the unexplored potential.

[Garry/Al-Fan]

ALPHA FLIGHT

Shaman [Michael Twoyoungmen] - 10
Aurora - 9 1/2
Sasquatch (Walter Langkowski) - 9 1/2
Snowbird (Anne McKenzie) - 9 1/2
Talisman [Elizabeth Twoyoungmen] - 9 1/2
Puck [Eugene & Zuzha] - both 9s
Box/Roger Bochs - 8 1/2
Agent K (personal favorite) - 8
Major Mapleleaf (Lou, Jr.) - 8
Marrina - 8
Northstar - 7 1/2

OMEGA FLIGHT

August D'Angelo - 10
The Master - 10
Gary Cody - 10
Delphine Courtney (real woman/"hot chick"/model for robot) - 9 1/2
Diamond Lil - 9 1/2
Box/Madison Jeffries - 9 1/2
Caliber - 9
Earthmover - 9
Flashback (allegiance kinda shakey) - 9
Smart Alec - 9
A "Mac" clone/synthoid/whatever - 9

HONORABLE MENTIONS

The ghost of Michael Twoyoungmen's grandfather - 10+
The Great Beasts (all seven) - 10
THE OLD GODS - 10
PESTILENCE - 10
Male Scorpio & The Zodiac - 10
Nemesis (whoever it is/not going to be picky about who) - 10
Marrina/Plodex captive from Collector's ship - 9 1/2
Douglas Thompson - 9
Director X - 8
Man-Bot - 8
Epsilon-Black - 8
Kara Killgrave/Persuasion - 7 1/2
Murmur - 7 1/2
Whitman Knapp (as a villian, and you know what I want to happen to him) - 7 1/2
Ghost Girl/Lili or Lilli - 7
Ouija - 7
Yukon Jack - 7
Flex - 4

[-K-M-]

Much better great to get some input, later I will read it...but now it's nap time

[Weapon Omega]

A Couple Of My Favorites:

Puck-10
Madison Jeffries-10 (Love this guy)
Northstar-9
Wild Child-9


Villains:

Master-10 (he IS Alpha's Archnemesis!)


On a side note:

Johnny Canuck...2 things
1. It's great to see someone rate Tech Noir so high, I always thought she had potential

2. The feral looking guy from Omega Flight is called SINEW

Take Care

[-K-M-]

I always thought Alpha Flight needed better villians.

Anyways Weapon Omega, geez I havn't heard that for awhile

[Weapon Omega]

King M:

I know what you mean! The Master of the World IS about it as Alpha Villains go. Omega Flight could be cool if Marvel could come up with a better roster of villains, those one-dimensional 'Z'-Listers didn't quite cut it.

Weapon Omega? Yeah, I wanted something a little obscure for the Alpha Waves Forum. I don't know, after reading Alpha Flight vol. #1 issue 102 I always thought the all-black "stealth" suits looked great. Too bad that's the only issue they EVER appear in!! Welcome to the forum man!!

[JohnnyCanuck]

Johnny Canuck...2 things
1. It's great to see someone rate Tech Noir so high, I always thought she had potential

2. The feral looking guy from Omega Flight is called SINEW

Take Care

I really liked her what can I say, and thanks for the name assist on Sinew.


JC